Page locked

This page is currently locked for editing by another user. You have to wait until this user finishes editing or the lock expires.
Currently locked by: 3.134.113.26
Lock expires at: 2025/04/19 06:07 (13 min)
This page is read only. You can view the source, but not change it. Ask your administrator if you think this is wrong.
====== Eternal Conscious Torment is the true Protestant Hell ======
===== Assumptions =====
  * [[The Laws of Logic hold universally]]
  * [[Protestant/Evangelical]] [[Christianity]]'s distinctive, characteristic beliefs

===== Definitions =====
Eternal Conscious Torment: the belief that Hell involves humans suffering in absolute torment, fully conscious and aware of that torment, from the moment they enter and for all of eternity.


===== Reasoning =====

  * [[The punishment of those in Hell lasts forever]]
  * [[Hell is experienced consciously]]]
  * [[Hell is torment]]
  * If the above is true, [[]]
∴ [[]]

===== Reasoning =====

  * [[The three sources of authority on the subject of Hell are the Old Testament, the intertestamental Jews, and the New Testament]]
  * [[Together, the Old Testament, intertestamental Jews, and the New Testament support Eternal Conscious Torment]]
  * If the above is true, [[]]
∴ [[]]
<code>
  * [[xThe Old Testament is against Eternal Conscious Torment]]
  * [[Intertestamental Jews supported Eternal Conscious Torment]]
  * [[The New Testament supports Eternal Conscious Torment]]
</code>
===== Reasoning =====

  * [[There are goods created by Eternal Conscious Torment]]
  * [[The goods created by Eternal Conscious Torment are necessary for a true Hell]]
  * [[These goods are necessary for a true Hell]]((Devnote: A good system would automatically recognize this and add the more formal reprhasing, "If something is the best possible Hell, it will have all of these goods." This aids in clearing up subsequent argumentation, as we can see later in this argument structure.))
  * [[If something is the best possible Hell, it is the true Hell]]((Devnote: For syncing an argument like this, it could be suggested to sync it with a meta-argument, "If something is the best possible x, it is the most plausible x." Arguments like these often come down to definition: as in, the definition of "best" here (which would be in the hover-text) directly coincides with the idea of being the most plausible, not with the idea of being the most pleasant.))
  * [[No other argument has all of these goods]]((Devnote: A really good system would recognize that this argument flows best in logic when paired with the argument two above it ("These goods are necessary for the best possible Hell"), especially after rephrasing it. So, a really good system would suggest to automatically move this argument up one position for clarity. The order of the arguments is not something I explain much in the Notes page, but is something I hope every user will be able to pick up on/learn.))
  * If the above is true, [[]]
∴ [[]]

===== Notable Supporters =====
[[wp>Jonathan Edwards (theologian)]] in [[http://www.jonathan-edwards.org/Eternity.html|Eternity of Hell Torments]]

====== Counter-Statement ======
[[xEternal Conscious Torment is the true Protestant Hell]]


====== Talk ======
Interestingly, a lot of arguments against Hell are actually against the eternality of Hell--an argument that is (mostly) unique to ECT: thus, instead of putting them as a rebuttal to Hell itself, it is best that they are moved here (users, even submitters, will find things like this and move them themselves. On the other thread, "Hell exists," Hell would simply be defined as something like "a place after death for at least some people to be damned to by some Being or Force."
-Loyal

It would be helpful to refine which exact positions Edwards supports by putting it under the reasoning, such as
<code>
===== Reasoning =====

  * [[foo]]
  * If the above is true, [[]]
∴ [[]]
==== Notable Supporters ====
[[wp>Jonathan Edwards (theologian)]] in [[http://www.jonathan-edwards.org/Eternity.html|Eternity of Hell Torments]]

===== Reasoning =====
</code> -Loyal
User Tools

Site Tools

Page locked

Page Tools
