Devnote: This is an interesting OR argument (not the standard OR in an AND/OR argument, but a disjunction argument). However, this does not seem to be the preferred way of presenting the statement; a better way would be “If xthe damned have committed infinitely evil crimes, xEternal Conscious Torment torturing is consistent with the justice of God.” In the attempt to have one right way to represent every argument, If-then statements are always preferred.

Devnote: Someone will eventually try to rephrase this as “Sin is finite” and “the debt is finite.” These would likely be accepted. Interestingly, this would mean that the community is accepting the proposition that “people have committed infinitely evil crimes” and “sin/debt is finite” are logical opposites, where if one is true, the other is false, and if one is false, the other is true.